Abstract
This is a cross sectional study of a sample of civil servants from the interior of Sao Paulo state, carried out with the purpose of evaluating the occurrence of unwanted pregnancies, the proportion which were terminated, the reason given for having or not having an abortion and which factors were associated to the decision whether or not to terminate an unwanted pregnancy. Just over one fifth declared to have experienced an unwanted pregnancy and over half of them were aborted. The reasons to abort concentrate on interferance with their life expectancy: to continue studying or working being single , too young to get married and to become a father or mother . Also important were fear of parents and rejection by the respondents'partner. Among those who did not terminate the unwanted pregnancy religion acted as a barrier among almost one third and the legal barrier for almost one fourth. Not having a permanent partner, being in use of behavioral or barrier method of contraception and higher education were associated with higher incidence of abortion of the unwanted pregnancy, but in multiple regression, only higher education remain significantly associated. Our results showed that once the unwanted pregnancy occur, more than half of them will be aborted, confirming the need to concentrate the efforts in reducing unwanted pregnancies if we want to prevent abortion.
Author Contributions
Copyright© 2019
Ferreira Bento Silvana, et al.
License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Competing interests The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Funding Interests:
Citation:
Results
The socio-demographic characteristics of the participants are shown on Information missing for 24 participants on age, for 12 on sex, 16 on schooling, 10 on marital status, 59 for living children and 35 on family income. A relatively large proportion of the sample (214 out of 1660, or 12.9%) did not respond the question about history of having an unwanted pregnancy. One fourth (20.5%) of the respondents reported having had the experience of an absolutely unwanted pregnancy in themselves, if female, or with their partner, if male. Over half of those pregnancies were aborted, as shown in Information missing for 214 respondents. Almost one third of the respondents gave moral or religious reasons for not aborting an absolutely unwanted pregnancy and one fourth reported lack of knowledge, money or courage; these and the other reasons are shown on Information missing for 10 participants. # Some participants gave more than one reason The most frequent reason for deciding to terminate the unwanted pregnancy was being single with 37%. Arround 30% aborted because the male partner did not accept that he was the father, for fear of their parents reaction and in order to keep studying. Almost one fourth felt that they were too young to become a mother or father. Only 6% referred to financial problems ( Information missing for three participants. Some participants gave more than one reason The decision to abort the unwanted pregnancy was associated to not having a permanent partner, higher educational level and using barrier or behavioral methods of contraception at the time of getting pregnant, in bivariate analysis ( The main reason for not using a contraceptive method at the time the woman got pregnant was that she did not expect to have a sexual relation (39% of cases) and in an additional 11% the male promised to use a condom, but did not used it. Only 5% did not have information on contraception. Respondents gave a variety of other reasons related to lack of responsibility and disbelief that they could get pregnant (Data not shown in tables). The Poisson regression showed that the only factor being independently associated to terminate the unwanted pregnancy was having higher education (
Characteristics
n
%
Age (n=1.636)
18 – 29
153
9.4
30 – 49
980
59.9
≥ 50
503
30.7
Sex (n=1648)
Female
1204
73.1
Male
444
26.9
Schooling (n=1644)
Up to secondary
495
30.1
Higher education
1149
69.9
Marital status (n=1650)
In stable union
1030
62.4
Not in union
620
37.6
Total of living children (n=1601)
None
485
30.3
1 – 2
857
53.5
≥ 3
259
16.2
Family income (n=1625)
Up to 10 minimum wages
1025
63.1
>10 minimum wages
600
36.9
GRAND TOTAL
1660
Absolutely unwanted pregnancy and abortion
n
%
Had and aborted
165
11.4
Had and did not abort
131
9.1
Did not have such experience
1150
79.5
Total
1446
Male partner does not recognize
51
31.5
Fear of parents reaction
50
30.9
To continue studying
47
29.0
Too young to be mother/father
38
23.5
To keep working
25
15.4
Did not want to get married
23
14.2
Financial problems
10
6.2
Total
162
Main reasons
n
%
Being single
60
37.0
Male partner does not recognize
51
31.5
Fear of parents reaction
50
30.9
To continue studying
47
29.0
Too young to be mother/father
38
23.5
To keep working
25
15.4
Did not want to get married
23
14.2
Financial problems
10
6.2
Total
162
Characteristics
n
(%)
Total
p-value
Sex
Female
111
53.1
209
0.199
Male
54
62.1
87
Age at the time of the pregnancy (years)
≤ 17
16
47.1
34
0.224
18 – 24
81
62.3
130
≤ 25
59
55.1
107
Number of children
0
123
58.9
209
0.309
1 or more
37
48.7
76
Marital status
In union
32
41.6
77
Not in union
129
61.7
209
Years of schooling
Primary
34
47.9
71
Secondary
36
42.9
84
Higher
90
70.3
128
Contraceptive used at the time of pregnancy
None
44
47.3
93
Modern
30
46.2
65
Barrier/behavioral
88
68.8
128
Dependent variable: aborting an unwanted pregnancy
RP
IC 95% para RP
p-value
Years of schooling at the time of unwanted pregnancy
Up to secondary school
1
Higher education
1.71
1.19-2,47
0.004
Discussion
According to the answer of the interviewees, only 20% had experienced an absolutely unwanted pregnancy and only 11% had aborted. These percentages are much lower than the proportion of women who declared to have aborted found in other studies with similar populations, but where face to face interviews were used to collect the information As abortion is basically illegal in Brazil, it is to be expected that an unknown proportion of those who responded a self reported questionnaire did not trust the confidentiality of the data collection and were not willing to declare to have done something that is punished as a crime in this country. The difficulty to obtain correct information on abortion has already been shown in our population Looking at the reasons given to terminate their pregnancy by those who declared to have aborted, it is clear that the reasons concentrate around answers which indicated that the pregnancy interfered with their life expectancy: to continue studying or working being single , too young to get married and to become a father or mother . Also important were indicators of family or partnership disfunction, such as fear of parents and denial of responsibility for the pregnancy by the partner. As reason to abort, the little relevance of finantial problems is a disagreement with a similar study carried out in 1990, where financial problems was given as a reason for abortion by almost three quarters of the respondents of a mail survey Among those who did not terminate an unwanted pregnancy it appears that religion acted as a barrier among almost one third of them and the legal barrier for almost one fourth. The effect of religion over opinion and behavior related to abortion has been already described in a number of studies on abortion and it is not a surprise The fear of committing a crime punished by law is also understandable, and it may have also been a reason for the relatively low proportion of subjects who declared to have had an abortion. The high proportion of respondent, over three quarters, who did not gave this reason for not having a abortion is in agreement with the international acknowledgement that women who decide to terminate a pregnancy do so in a similar proportion independently of the legal conditions of abortion in the country they live The significant association of higher educational level with a higher chance of having an abortion when confronted with an unwanted pregnancy is also in agreement with earlier studies, which shows that although women with higher education had less risk of having an unintended and unawanted pregnancy, when they get pregnant against their will, they do have a higher risk of aborting The significantly higher proportion of abortion among those who were using a barrier or behavioral method of contraception, in comparison with those using none or modern methods was not expected, considering that behavioral methods are promoted by religious groups, which also oppose to abortion. However, as the correlation disappears in the multiple regression analysis it may be that it only reflects that women with higher education use behavioral and barrier methods more often than those with lower eduation The main limitation of this study is that it is based in the data obtained from a self-responded questionnaire and it is impossible to estimate how well those who responded represent the universe of public servant we intended to reach. It means that the percentages of participants with history of unwanted pregnancy and abortion are not necessarily representative of the population of civil servant in the interior of the state of Sao Paulo that we intended to sample. It doesn t mean, however, that the reason given for having or not having abortion is not valid, as that is not dependent on which proportion responded and on possible selection bias. We also did not explore in this study, what happened with the babies born from unwanted pregnancies which were not ternminated. A study had suggested that those babies are at higher risk or morbidity and mortality that babies born from planned pregnancies Our results showing that more than half of the respondents who have an unwanted pregnancy decided to terminate their pregnancies, contributes to confirm that the most important means to prevent abortion is by preventing unwanted pregnancies. Such purpose is achieved by facilitating access to information and provision of modern contraceptives, incluing long acting method given at no cost We hope that the publication of these results contribute to estimulate authorities to promote and carry out the interventions known to be effective in reducing unwanted pregananciess and abortion, instead of insisting in keeping abortion illegal, which has been shown to be ineffective to achieve that purpose