Abstract
Adolescents is the transition from childhood to adulthood .Which is a time of opportunity, but also one of risk. In Ethiopia, sexual and reproductive health problems of adolescents are increasing from time to time related to many parents not feeling happy to discuss sexual matters in addition to early sexual commencement among adolescents.
This study was intended to assess parent-adolescent communication on sexual and reproductive health matters and associated factors among secondary and preparatory school students in Robe Town, Bale Zone, South East Ethiopia, 2017.
Institution based cross sectional study was conducted among 394 secondary and preparatory school students in Robe town from April 10-25, 2017. Simple random sampling technique was used. Data was obtained through the use of a self administered questionnaire and supplemented by focus group discussion with parents. Data was entered using Epi Data 3.1 and analyzed by SPSS 20. Descriptive statistics and logistic regression analyses were done. Data quality was assured through careful questionnaire design, pretest and training.
One hundred eighty six (47%) of the study participants had discussed at least two SRH issues with their parents. Grade eleven students were about nearly five times more likely discussed on sexual and reproductive matters with their parent compared with grade nine students (AOR: 4.88, 95% CI: 1.76, 13.54). Those living with relatives were 3.13 times less likely discussed as compared to those students are living with both parents (AOR: 0.32, 95%CI: (0.12, 0.80) and the odds of discussion on SRH matters is 2 times higher among females compared with their counterpart (AOR=2.02, 95% CI: 1.25, 3.26).
Communication on sexual and reproductive health matters between adolescent and parent was low. Majority of student preferred to discuss with their peers than parent. Being ashamed, parents lack of communication skill and parent knowledge on SRH issues were the major reasons mentioned by the students for not discussing about SRH matters with their parents. Therefore; comprehensive family life education needs to be initiated for the students and parents. Sexual information exchange between peers needs to be strengthened.
Author Contributions
Copyright© 2019
Mengesha Habte Niguse, et al.
License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Competing interests The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Funding Interests:
Citation:
Introduction
Adolescents are defined by the United Nations as those between the ages of 10 and 19 Adolescents experience intense physical, psychological, emotional and economic changes as they make the transition from childhood to adulthood. Risk-taking is part of adolescence, and it is the duty of society to prevent risk and to mitigate consequences such risk-taking behavior In Ethiopia, a lot of adolescents often lack strong and stable relationships with their parents or other adults which are necessary to openly discuss reproductive health concerns. Therefore, many teenagers do not have access to reliable information regarding their RH needs. In most cultures, parents and family members are an influential source of knowledge, beliefs, attitudes, and values for children and young people. Parents often have the power to guide children’s development in sexual health matters, encouraging them to practice reasonable sexual behavior and develop good personal decision making skills Communication within the family appears to be particularly important during the adolescent years especially concerning reproductive health issues. Family communication affects adolescent identity formation and role–taking ability The majority of people become sexually active during adolescence. The use of contraceptives and condoms among young people, however, is low and unprotected sex is the second largest contributor to health risk in terms of the burden of disease in young people. As a consequence, each year, there are at least 100 million cases of sexually transmitted infections among young people, as well as more than 2.5 million unsafe abortions recorded for adolescents Specifically in Ethiopia, 13 percent of women age 15-19 have begun childbearing with 10 percent having had a live birth and two percent pregnant with their first child. Teenage mothers are more likely to experience adverse pregnancy outcomes and are more constrained in their ability to pursue educational opportunities than young women who delay childbearing. There has not been a study done related to this subject in our area, so it is important to know the prevalence of parent adolescent discussion on sexual and reproductive health issues in our area
Results
In this study a total of 394 students were included with response rate of 100%. The mean age of respondents’ was 16.71 with standard deviation of 1.44 years. From the study participants, 212 (53.8%) were female. Majority of the respondents were 309 (78.4%) Oromo ethnic group and 178 (45.2%) were Muslims. 286 (72.5%) were living with both parents ( Three hundred eight (78.2%) of the respondents mentioned that they have got sexual and reproductive health information. Among thistwo hundred eighty six (92.8%) of the respondents heard information on sexual and reproductive health issues from school which is followed by mass media 91 (29.5%) ( Three hundred seventy four (94.9%) of the students had agreed on the importance of discussion on sexual and reproductive health matters with their family. It was also supported by majority of participants who involved in focus group discussion as communication between parent and adolescent on sexual and reproductive health matters since parents needs to play vital role in shaping their children behavior during adolescent age particularly regarding premarital sex and unwanted pregnancy but they have a gap of knowledge regarding sexual health. This is evident from the response, “We are supposed to tell our adolescents everything that has to do so with reproductive health. But I do not feel that we know all information they need,” (a 38-year-old female discussant). However, 186(47.2%) of students had ever discussed on at least two sexual and reproductive health topics with their parents. Large number of the study participants 228(57.9%) had reported as they have discussed on condom from which 223(56.6%) of them undertaken the discussion with their friends/peers. Majority of them 89% discussed some times. The majority of the students discussed on different sexual and reproductive health matters with their peers/friends followed by with sisters. From the total female participants, majority of them has seen their first menses at the age of fourteen years which account for 17.8% followed by fifteen years of age (15.7%). About 20(9.4%) of study participants had discussion before they have seen their first menses. Nearly 65% of them had a discussion with their sisters about menses before they have seen it followed by with peers (45%) ( One hundred nine (27.7%) of the students haddiscussed about contraceptive ( Multiple responses were possible. Data presented as n (%). Multiple responses were possible. Data presented as n (%).Factors associated with student-parent communication about sexual and reproductive health matters One hundred thirty one (33.2%) of the students haddiscussed about STI/HIV/AIDs. From those had a discussion, 109 (27.7%) and 47 (11.9%) discussed with their peers and sisters respectively ( One hundred three (26.1%) of the students discussed about sexual intercourse ( From focus group discussion, a female participant said that, “ One hundred nineteen (30.2%) of the students had discussed about unwanted pregnancy ( One hundred thirteen (28.7%) of the students had discussed about premarital sex ( One 50 years old male parent said “keep their virginity until marriage almost all of the discussants agreed on a virgin girl in our community is respected ” (50 years old male FGD participant). Two hundred twenty eight (57.9%) of the students had discussed about condom ( One mother said that “discussing about condom is opening the way or initiating our children to have sex” (32 years old female FGD participant). One hundred twelve (28.4%) of the students had discussed about puberty ( One hundred fifteen (29.2%) of the students had discussed about menstrual cycle ( In this case one female participants of focus group discussion mention “I frequently discuss with my child regarding menses with the purpose of developing her confidence since the issue is naturally occurs on human being” 34 years female FGD participants. But majority of participants did not discussed on menses as a result of discomfort and shame of dealing with children. With regard to adolescents major reasons for not discussing sexual and reproductive matters with their family, about 261 (66.2%) of students reported as shameful hindered them for discussing about sexual intercourse followed by parent’s lack of communication skill which account for 252 (64.0%). In general, being ashamed, parent’s lack of communication skill and lack of parents’ knowledge about sexual and reproductive health issues were the major reasons mentioned by the students for not discussing about sexual and reproductive health matters with their parents. The reason not discussing RH issues is bound by several socio cultural norms and expectations: “In our culture discussing about sexual issues is very rare. Let alone discussing with your child, wife-husband discussion on this issue is not experienced. Everybody is shy about it. These culture, taboo and traditions are passing from generation to generation. We were brought up like this and are doing it today,” (45-year-old female parent). Bivariate logistic regression analysis was performed to assess association between each independent variable and outcome variable. Results of bivariate analysis showed that grade level, sex of student, mother occupation, mother education status, father education status, living arrangement and family size become significantly associated with parent adolescent communication. Multivariate analysis was performed to identify factors independently associated with parent adolescent communication. In the multivariate analysis those variables with a p value <0.25 in the bivariate analysis were included and backward stepwise model was used. In the multivariate analysis, and the Hosmer- Lemeshow test indicates a p > 0.05 which signifies that the overall model fit is good. From 11 variable entered in to the multivariate analysis four of the variable including sex of student being female, being student grade 11, student from father education status diploma and above and students living with relative/friend or living alone were significantly associated with parent adolescent communication after controlling for confounders ( Otherincludes farmer and no mother, p value, p<0.05, p<0.001, 1 reference group Accordingly, students whose father education diploma and above were 3.35 times more likely to have parent adolescent communication than students whose father were illiterate (AOR, 3.35 95% CI (1.73, 6.47)). It was also found that, grade 11th students were 4.88 times more likely discussed on sexual and reproductive health matters with their parent compared with grade 9th students (AOR: 4.88 95%CI: (1.76, 13.54)). In this study, female study participants were nearly 2 times more likely to discussed about sexual and reproductive health matters with their parents when compared with their counterparts (AOR: 2.02 95%CI: (1.25, 3.26)). Again the odd of parent adolescent communication Study participants whose living arrangement were with relatives were less likely discussed on sexual and reproductive matters when compared with those students living with both parents ((AOR: 0.32 95%CI: (0.12, 0.80)). However, factors that were statistically significantly in the bivariate analysis like mother education, mother occupation and family size were not showed statistically significant association in the multivariate analysis after controlling for confounders
Age
13-16 years
182
46.2
17-19 years
212
53.8
Sex
Male
182
46.2
Female
212
53.8
Religion
Orthodox
174
44.1
Muslim
178
45.2
Protestant
33
8.4
Others
9
2.3
Ethnicity
Amhara
64
16.2
Oromo
309
78.4
Gurage
10
2.6
Tigrie
5
1.3
Other
6
1.5
Marital status of parents
Together
328
83.2
Separated
22
5.6
Divorced
28
7.1
Widowed
16
4.1
With whom are you living
With father and mother
286
72.5
With mother
45
11.4
With father
11
2.8
Friends
14
3.6
Alone
22
5.6
Relatives
16
4.1
Mother educational status
Illiterate
34
8.6
Read and write only
87
22.1
Primary school
136
34.5
Secondary school
76
19.3
Diploma
25
6.3
Degree
31
7.9
No mother
5
1.3
Father educational status
Illiterate
23
5.8
Read and write only
64
16.2
Primary school
34
8.6
Secondary school
136
34.5
Diploma
24
6.1
Degree
97
24.6
No Father
16
4.1
Occupation of mother
House wife
221
56.1
Employed (private)
28
7.1
Employed (government)
39
9.9
Merchant
77
19.5
Farmer
24
6.1
No Mother
5
1.3
Occupation of Father
Employed (private)
28
7.1
Employed (government)
142
3.6
Merchants
47
11.9
Farmer
138
35
No Father
19
4.8
Other
20
5.1
Family size
< 5
243
61.7
>=5
151
38.3
Topic of discussion
With whom they had discussed
Discussed
Contraceptive
109(27.7)
30(7.6)
64(16.2)
61(15.5)
48(12.2)
30(7.6)
2(0.5)
STI/HIV/AIDS
131(33.2)
24(6.1)
38(9.6)
109(27.7)
47(11.9)
34(8.6)
16(4.2)
Sexual intercourse
103(26.1)
21(5.3)
38(9.6)
81(20.6)
42(10.7)
26(6.6)
1(0.3)
Unwanted pregnancy
119(30.2)
6(1.5)
36(9.1)
96(24.4)
62(15.7)
9(2.3)
2(0.6)
Premarital sex
113(28.7)
13(3.3)
41(10.4)
91(23.1)
42(10.7)
14(3.6)
1(0.3)
Condom
228(57.9)
2(0.5)
4(1.0)
223(56.6)
41(10.4)
27(6.9)
14(3.6)
Pubertal stage
112(28.4)
9(2.3)
17(4.3)
85(21.6)
60(15.2)
12(3.0)
7(1.8)
Menstrual cycle
115(29.2)
3(0.8%)
48(12.2)
74(18.8)
52(13.2)
2(0.5)
0(0)
Topic of discussion
Reasons for not discussing about SRH
Not discussed
Contraceptive
285(72.3)
182(46.2)
254(64.5)
198(50.3)
237(60.2)
136(34.5)
169(42.9)
STI/HIV/AIDS
263(66.8)
166(42.1)
233(59.1)
187(47.5)
227(57.6)
137(34.8)
171(43.4)
Sexual intercourse
291(73.9)
181(45.9)
261(66.2)
213(54.1)
252(64.0)
143(36.3)
188(47.7)
Unwanted pregnancy
275(69.8)
174(44.2)
245(62.2)
202(51.3)
222(56.3)
145(36.8)
176(44.7)
Premarital sex
281(71.3)
169(42.9)
250(63.5)
192(48.7)
239(60.7)
138(35.0)
172(43.7)
Condom
166(42.1)
126(32.0)
136(34.5)
124(31.5)
109(27.7)
96(24.4)
123(31.2)
Pubertal stage
282(71.6)
175(44.4)
241(61.2)
197(50.0)
223(56.6)
140(35.5)
180(45.7)
Menstrual cycle
97(24.6)
78(19.8)
97(24.6)
80(20.3)
96(24.4)
60(15.2)
65(16.5)
Variables
Communication on SRH
Crude OR (95%CI)
AOR(95%CI)
Yes
No
Sex
MaleFemale
63123
11989
12.61(1.73, 3.93)
12.02 (1.25, 3.26)
Grade
9th10th11th12th
65872113
10280917
11.71 (1.10, 2.64)3.66 (1.58, 8.49)
11.16 (0.70, 1.92)4.88 (1.76, 3.54)
Living arrangement
With both parentsWith single parentWith friends/ relatives or alone
1581810
1314037
10.37 (0.20, 0.68) 0.22 (0.11, 0.47)
10.84 (0.35. 2.01)0.32 (0.12, 0.80
Mother education
IlliteratePrimary schoolDiploma and aboveNo mother
3968772
8759593
12.57 (1.54, 4.29)
Fathers education
IlliteratePrimary schoolDiploma and aboveNo father
219151 5
702110611
11.13 (0.46, 2.80)4.48 (2.58, 7.76)
10.74 (0.26, 2.01)3.35 (1.73, 6.47)
Mother occupation
HousewifeEmployed (Gov`t or private)MerchantOther
11034384
120293920
11.28 (0.73, 2.240)1.06 (0.63, 1.78)0.22 (0.072, 0.66)
Family size
<5>=5
85101
15850
13.75 (2.44, 5.77)
Discussion
Parents play an essential role in the betterment of adolescents' lives through communicating various issues particularly sexual and reproductive health matters. They have a unique role in influencing the decisions and behaviors of their adolescent children related to sexual and reproductive health issues based on their willingness to communicate on such topics. This study has tried to assess level of parent-adolescent communication on sexual and reproductive health issues and factors associated with it. Accordingly, about 186 (47.2%) of the students has discussed on two and more sexual and reproductive topic with their parents. The result is lower when seen with the finding of the research conducted on barriers of parent-adolescent communication on sexual and reproductive health issues among school students in Yirgalem town which showed 59% parent-adolescent discussion on sexual and reproductive health issues It is higher when compared with a longitudinal study in Tanzania that showed 27% of parent-adolescent communication about sexual and reproductive health With regard to with whom the student had discussed sexual and reproductive health matters, majority of study participants had undertaken the discussion with peers followed by with sisters. It is in line with the study done on barriers of parent-adolescent communication on sexual and reproductive health issues among school students in Yirgalem town which showed that, students more likely preferred to communicate sister and peers In multivariate analysis, level of father education showed strong statistical association with communication about sexual and reproductive health. Adolescents whose father s education diploma and above were 3.35 times more likely to have parent adolescent communication than students whose fathers were illiterate. This is congruent with previous finding from study done in Rwanda It was also found that, grade level of students to be statistically linked with parent-adolescents communication. Grade 11th students were 4.88 times more likely discussed on sexual and reproductive matters with their parent compared with grade 9th students. This finding was similar with the study done in Western Ethiopia and Debremarkos Sex of the study participants was found to be statistically associated with parent- adolescent communication on sexual and reproductive health matters. Female study participants were nearly 2 times more likely to discussed about sexual and reproductive health matters with their parents when compared with their counterparts. The result of this study was comparable when compared with the study done in Rwanda where males did not discuss sexual matters compared to the female students In contrary to this study done Benishangul Gumuz revealed that male were more likely to communicate on parent adolescent communication In this study, with whom student live was found to be significantly associated with parent-adolescents communication on sexual and reproductive matters. Study participants whose living arrangement were with relatives or friend or students who live alone were less likely discussed on sexual and reproductive matters when compared with those students living with both parents. The finding is in line with a research done on parent-adolescent communication about sexual and reproductive health in Mekele town where students living with both parents were two times to communicate on SRH issue when compared with students living with others However, this finding was not supported by a study done in Awabel woreda, Northwest Ethiopia as young people who were living with their fathers were more likely to discuss on SRH topics However, factors that were statistically significantly in another study like age of student, mother education and family size were not showed statistically significant association in the present study. The reason might be there is no difference on parent adolescent communication with respect to age of student, mother education status and family size in the present study area. The study used mixed method of quantitative and qualitative method which allowed triangulation of the findings of the study.
Conclusion
The study revealed that low level of parent-adolescent communication on sexual and reproductive health matters. From sexual and reproductive health topics discussed, discussion on condom was the leading one. Among those students had a discussion on sexual and reproductive health matters with their parents, majority of them had the discussion with peers followed by sisters Being ashamed, parent’s lack of communication skill and Lack of parental knowledge about sexual and reproductive health, were the major reasons mentioned by the students for not discussing about sexual and reproductive health matters with their parents. Sex, educational level of students, living arrangement of students and father educational level were identified as significantly associated with parent-adolescent communication on sexual and reproductive health matters. Hence provision of information, education and communication targeting adolescents and their parents to increase their awareness and practice regarding sexual and reproductive health matters is recommended.