Abstract
Acute malnutrition affects nearly 52 million of under five years children globally, 75% of them live in low to middle income countries. The treatment of acute malnutrition using supplement foods could help children recovering and could reduce the risk of sickness. The present study investigated the factors associated with recovery among children with moderate acute malnutrition (MAM) under a follow-up program at health facilities. A prospective study was conducted in 16 health centers of Kirehe District of Rwanda and included 200 children from 6 to 59 months. A semi-structured questionnaire was used for data collection. All children enrolled in the study spent three months in nutrition program at health centers. The results show that after 3 months in the program 77.5% recovered from MAM. Children aged above 36 to 59 months were recovered at 90% whereas children aged from 24-35 months were recovered at 73.5%. Micronutrients and deworming provided at health facility were contributed to the recovery as children who received them were recovered at 89.1% and for those who didn t were recovery at 72.1%. The findings demonstrated that boys were 16 times more likely to recover from MAM in three months of intervention than girls (AOR=16.19, p<0.001, 95% CI: 5.39- 48.63). Children from moderate income families were 3 more likely to recover than those from very low income families (AOR=2.8, p=0.029, 95% CI: 1.11-7.51). Male gender, receiving micronutrients and deworming from health facilities and family income status were factors associated with MAM recovery status
Author Contributions
Copyright© 2020
Bihibindi Kabundi Vianney, et al.
License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Competing interests The authors declare that they have n competing interests, which may have inappropriate influenced them in writing this article.
Funding Interests:
Citation:
Materials And Methods
A prospective study was conducted in 16 health centers of Kirehe District in Rwanda. A total of 200 children with Moderate Acute Malnutrition under Nutrition program were followed-up for 3 months. On the first day of admission all children from 6 to 59 months were taken anthropometric measurements (weight, height, weight for height in z-score) by the socio-worker in charge of nutrition and all children diagnosed as Moderate Acute Malnutrition (MAM) or weight for height in z-score between -3≤WHF<-2 were enrolled in nutrition program for 3 months of treatment. The anthropometric measurements and the family socio-demographic characteristics were collected after every 2 weeks by hired nurses at health facility.By the end of three months, children were classified as recovered and discharged from nutrition program if found to have weight for height Z-score of over minus two . This study included 200 children aged 6 to 59 months under nutrition program called Supplementary Feeding programSFP) in health centers of Kirehe District from 1st January to 31st March 2019. The primary caregivers of these children were interviewed as they brought their children for anthropometrics measurement, physical exams, medical follow-up and treatment. Parents or caregivers were requested to sign a consent form and participation was voluntary. Data on anthropometrics measurement (weight, height, z-score) were captured from Supplementary Feeding Program (SFP) registers. Data of the first day of admission of the child to the program served as baseline information. Some variable data were collected considering three months of food supplement treatment as the assessment or end line information. All the caregivers were asked the information regarding on clinical signs and symptoms, diagnostics and medications received at admission, types of foods received and their duration in the program. The intervention received was Corn Soy Beans (CSB), nurse consultation, laboratory examinations and treatment of infections if existing. Pre and post-anthropometric measurements and weight for height in z score were collected from the health study centres and used to determine the children who had recovered from MAM. A database was constructed in excel to serve as platform for data entry. After cleaning, data were imported into STATA version 15.1. Descriptive statistics such as mean and standard deviations for continuous variables were computed. For categorical variables frequency and percentages were calculated. A chi square test was conducted to measure the association and p-value was set at 5%. Logistic regression used to determine factors associated with recovery among the children with MAM and odds ratios with 95% CI were estimated to identify the factors associated with recovery. Permission to do a study was obtained from Mount Kenya University and Kirehe District Health Unit. Before beginning the study, clear explanation was given to mothers/caregivers and received their written informed consent. They were also being ensured their full right to leave from the study at any time they wish to do so without any inconvenience. The parents/caregivers were also assured that their responses were kept confidential and used to serve the purpose of the study.
Results
A total of 200 children were participated in the study and anthropometrics data were collected on height and weight of the children. All children with -3≤WFH<-2 were enrolled in the nutrition program for three months. ( Within the age group, children aged above 36 to 59 months were recovered at 90% whereas children aged 24-35 months were recovered at 73.5%. Male participants were highly recovered that female at 95.7% and 61.3% respectively. Recovery rate among children whom their caregivers are educated was high compare to not educate at 78.6% and 75.7% respectively. Micronutrients and deworming provided at health facility was contributed to the recovery as children who received them were recovered at 89.1% and for those who didn’t, were recovered at 72.1%. The family whose monthly income was varying above 5 thousand, their children was recovered from MAM at 88.7%. The respondents were asked the type of diet they had taken on the previous 24 hours prior to data collection. Result shows that the majority 81 (40.5%) reported that they ate cereals meals (corn flour porridge, cornmeal) in the last 24 hours ( Of the total of 200 respondents, 79 (39.5%) said that they ate legumes while 15 (7.5%) reported that they had porridge and legumes. Only 8 (4%) respondents ate the tubers and 6 (3%) ate porridge, legumes and fruits. A small proportion of 9 (4.5%) reported that they had animal protein (milk, meat, eggs), on the day before data collection. At 5% level of confidence, the chi-square test showed that gender, monthly income and micronutrients and deworming provided were significantly associated with children’s recovery from MAM (p values were < 0.001, 0.007, and 0,011 respectively). ( The variables with less than 5% in the bivariate analysis were considered for logistic regression. In the final multivariate analysis adjusted model, socio-demographic variables which are gender and family income were found to be associated with children’ recovery. The The present study showed that also other factor that was associated to the children’s recovery was other treatments (micronutrients and deworming) provided at health facility. For other treatment, those who did not receive micronutrients and deworming were 2.9 more likely to recover and this may be due to effect comorbidities to plan interventions meaning that they did not present other medical problems during the course of treatment for MAM enhancing quick recovery (AOR=2.9, p=0.027, 95% CI: 1.13-7.58).
Variable
Category
Recovery status
Recovered n=155 (77.5%)n(%)
Not recovery n=45(22.5%)n(%)
Age
Less than or equal 23 months
112 (76.7)
34 (23.3)
24-35 months
15 (73.5)
9 (26.5)
Greater than 36
18 (90)
2 (10.0)
Gender
Female
65 (61.3)
41 (38.7)
Male
90 (95.7)
4 (4.3)
Number of children
1-2 children
96 (77.42)
28 (22.6)
3-4 children
30 (69.8)
13 (30.2)
More than 4 children
29 (87.9)
4 (12.1)
Education level of
Not educated
56 (75.7)
18 (24.3)
parents or caregiver
Educated
99 (78.6)
227 (21.4)
Milk intake
Once a day
11 (78.6)
3 (21.4)
Twice a day
124 (79)
33 (21)
More than 2 times per day
20 (69)
9 (31)
Source of foods
Through income
41 (78.9)
11 (21.1)
Working for foods
19 (65.5)
10 (34.5)
Supports
95 (79.8)
24 (20.1)
Micronutrients and deworming
No
98 (72.1)
38 (27.9)
Yes
57 (89.1)
7 (10.9)
Monthly income
Less than or equal 5k
100 (72.5)
38 (27.5)
Greater than 5k
55 (88.7)
7 (11.3)
Alcohol abuse
No
77 (72.6)
29 (27.4)
yes
78 (83)
16 (17)
Breastfeeding
Up to 6 months
2 (100)
0
6 plus
153 (77.3)
45 (22.7)
Foods share
No
97 (77)
29 (23)
Yes
58 (78.4)
16 (21.6)
Use of latrine
Community latrine
93 (80.2)
23 (19.8)
Neighbor’s latrine
2 (100)
0
Private latrine
60 (73.2)
22 (26.5)
Cereals meals ( corn flour porridge, cornmeal)
81
40.5
Animal protein source
9
4.5
Legumes
79
39.5
Porridge
2
1
Porridge and legumes
15
7.5
Porridge, legumes & fruits
6
3
Tubers
8
4
Variable
Category
Frequency
X²
P value
Recovered n=155 (77.5%)
Not recovery n=55 (22.5%)
Age
<= 23 months
112 (76.7)
34 (23.3)
2.152
0.34
24-35months
25 (73.5)
9 (26.5)
Greater than 36
18 (90)
2 (10.0)
Gender
Female
65 (61.3)
41 (38.7)
33.86
<0.001
Male
90 (95.7)
4 (4.3)
Parenting
Orphans
43 (81.13)
10 (18.9)
0.55
0.46
Live parents
112 (76.19)
35 (23.81)
Insurance
Yes
93 (75)
31 (25)
1.169
0.279
No
62 (81.58)
14 (18.42)
Household size
1-3 children1-3
96 (77.42)
28(22.58)
3.514
0.173
3-4 children
30 (69.77)
13 (30.23)
More than 4 children
29 (87.88)
4 (12.12)
Education level of parents or caregivers
Not educated
56 (75.7)
18 (24.3)
0.224
0.64
Educated
99 (78.6)
27 (21.4)
Daily intake
Once a day
11 (78.6)
3 (21.4)
1.42
0.492
Twice a day
124 (79)
33 (21)
More than 2 times
20 (69)
9 (31)
Source of foods
Through income
41 (78.9)
11 (21.1)
2.813
0.245
Working for foods
19 (65.5)
10 (34.5)
Supports
95 (79.8)
24 (20.1)
Micronutrient & deworming
No
98 (72.1)
38 (27.9)
7.216
0.007
Yes
57(89.1)
7 (10.9)
Monthly income
Less than or equal 5k
100 (72.5)
38 (27.5)
6.475
0.011
Greater than 5k
55 (88.7)
7 (11.3)
Alcohol abuse
No
77 (72.6
29 (27.4)
3.035
0.081
Yes
78 (83)
16 (17)
Breastfeeding
Up to 6 months
2 (100)
0
0.586
0.444
6 plus
153 (77.3)
45 (22.7)
Food share
No
97 (77)
29 (23)
0.052
0.820
Yes
58 (78.4)
16 (21.6)
Use of latrine
Community latrine
93 (80.2)
23 (19.8)
1.937
0.380
Neighbor’s latrine
2 (100)
0
Private latrine
60 (73.2)
22 (26.5)
Variable
Category
AOR
P-value
95% CI
Gender
Female
Reference
Male
16.19
<0.001
5.39- 48.63
Receiving Micronutrients & deworming from health facility
No
Reference
Yes
2.9
0.027
1.13 -7.58
Monthly income
<=RWF5000
Reference
> RWF 5000
2.8
0.029
1.11 -7.51
Discussion
By referring on weight for height (WFH) measurements, children who achieved nutrition recovered was 77.5%. By running the bivariate and multivariate analysis, it was documented that factors identified to influence MAM recovery were being male; earning monthly greater than RWF 5000 and micronutrients and deworming provided apart from foods supplements at health facilities were associated to the recovery of children from MAM. A recent study conducted in Malawi A controlled comparative trial done in Malawi among moderately wasted children establish that 58% of children recovered when consuming Ready to Use Therapeutic Foods (RUTF), although only 22% recovered when using Corn Soy Beans (CSB) A study conducted in Indonesia A study conducted by Christine in 2013 The sex stratified analyses revealed that, through similar findings were retained for males, female wasting was more likely among girls with brothers. Such findings may be explained by preferential feeding or better hygiene of brothers as compared to their sisters, which may indicate low value placed on girls. A recent published series on maternal and child nutrition by the Lancet medical journal hypothesizes that improving women s empowerment is an important point of intervention for improving nutrition. The series explain that women s empowerment is the mechanism through which increase in income and yield for agricultural inputs affect intra household resource allocation and children s nutrition
Conclusion
The aim of the study was to assess factors that influence recovery among under five years’ children treated for MAM at Kirehe District health centers. The findings showed the proportion of 77.5% of recovery from MAM. It was revealed that small proportion of respondents feed on animal protein source. Male gender (AOR=16.19, p<0.001, 95% CI: 5.39-48.63), provision of micronutrients (AOR=2.9, p=0.027, 95% CI=1.13-7.58) and monthly income greater than RWF 5000 (AOR=2.8, p=0.029, 95% CI=1.11-7.51) where found to be associated with MAM recovery. In order to monitor the growth status of malnourished children under nutrition feeding program,community health workers need to visit families with malnourished children more often. The government should continue to provide micronutrients and nutrient food package to the poor families with malnourished children. There is a need to increase direct and indirect support received by poor families in Rwanda.