Reviewer Benefits
Reviewers contribute to the quality of JMPT while gaining professional recognition and insight into emerging trauma research. We value reviewer service and provide benefits that support academic development.
Benefits Overview
Benefits include formal recognition, access to journal updates, and opportunities to engage with the global trauma research community. Active reviewers may be considered for editorial roles.
Key Benefits
Certificate
Formal service recognition.
APC Discounts
Eligibility based on service.
Network
Global peer connections.
Editorial Pathway
Consideration for editor roles.
Additional Value
Reviewers receive certificates and acknowledgment for their contributions.
Reviewing strengthens critical evaluation skills and domain expertise.
Letters of service are available for institutional reporting.
Consistent reviewers may be invited to special issues or commentaries.
Reviewer Standards
Reviews should focus on methods, data integrity, and clinical relevance. Provide clear major and minor recommendations and point to specific sections for revision. Balanced feedback helps authors respond efficiently.
Recognition
Reviewers receive certificates and may be eligible for APC discounts based on service. Recognition letters can support professional development and institutional service reporting.
Confidentiality
Manuscripts are confidential. Do not share data or use unpublished findings. Destroy manuscript files after review to protect privacy and intellectual property.
Review Structure
Begin with a brief summary of the work, followed by major concerns and minor edits. Comment on ethical compliance, statistical reporting, and the clinical relevance of conclusions.
Declining Reviews
If you cannot review within the timeframe or lack expertise, decline promptly so the editor can reassign. Timely declines help keep decisions on schedule.
Bias and Sensitivity
Reviews should be free of personal bias and sensitive to trauma related topics. Focus on evidence, methods, and clarity, and avoid language that may stigmatize participants.
Confidential Reports
Use the confidential comments section for sensitive concerns, such as ethics issues or data integrity questions. This allows the editor to address issues discreetly while keeping author feedback constructive.
Timely Response
Confirm review invitations promptly and adhere to agreed deadlines. Timely reviews keep clinical findings moving toward publication and support author satisfaction.
Constructive Tone
Maintain a respectful, professional tone and focus on evidence based critiques. Constructive feedback improves manuscript quality and supports author development.
Scope Alignment
Focus on whether the manuscript fits JMPT scope and contributes to trauma care or recovery research.
Join the JMPT reviewer community
Register today and contribute to high quality trauma research.